The Real Cost of Keeping a Car on the Road Each Year

The monthly payment is only part of the bill. Here is what fuel, insurance, registration, maintenance and depreciation add up to, and how to judge whether an older car is still the cheaper choice.

Ask anyone what their car costs and they will usually name the monthly payment. That number leaves out most of the bill. AAA’s 2026 Your Driving Costs study puts the full cost of owning and operating a new vehicle at $12,863 a year, or $1,071.92 a month, and the same categories of expense apply to a car you already own. Laying them out line by line is the clearest way to judge whether an older vehicle is still worth keeping.

What a Car Costs Beyond the Payment

The payment itself varies with how you buy. According to credit reporting agency Experian, the average monthly payment in the second quarter of 2026 was $765 for a new car, $617 for a lease, and $542 for a used car. Whichever route you take, the payment eventually ends. The other costs do not.

Every year, a registered car carries some combination of these expenses:

  • Fuel, which AAA’s 2026 study averages at 17.3 cents per mile, or $2,595 for a 15,000-mile year
  • Insurance, which almost every state requires
  • Routine maintenance and unexpected repairs
  • Registration fees and, in many states, taxes tied to the vehicle
  • Depreciation, the slow loss of the car’s value

None of these disappear because a car is paid off. Two of them, insurance and registration, continue even if the car barely moves.

Routine Maintenance: Oil Changes, Tires, Brakes and Inspections

AAA’s 2016 study put average maintenance at $792 a year, about $66 a month, and noted that costs had been creeping up because of pricier semi-synthetic and full-synthetic motor oils, higher extended warranty prices, and rising shop labor rates. Costs vary a great deal by vehicle, and age and mileage push them higher. An older car needs the same oil changes and tire rotations as a newer one, plus parts that wear out with time, such as batteries, hoses, and suspension components.

Skipping the routine work tends to backfire. AAA found that 35 percent of drivers have skipped or delayed recommended service, and repair shops report that this habit leads to higher repair costs down the road. Small problems, like worn brake pads, are cheaper to fix before they damage the parts behind them.

The trade-off here is straightforward. Following the maintenance schedule in the owner’s manual costs money now, while deferring it risks larger bills and a shorter life for the car.

The Bills You Pay Even When the Car Sits Still

Insurance is usually the largest of these fixed costs. AAA’s 2026 study puts the average annual premium for full-coverage insurance at $2,098. A premium is the amount you pay, monthly or annually, for the policy itself. Rates vary widely with the driver, driving record, location, and the vehicle, so two neighbors can pay very different amounts for similar coverage. A deductible is the amount you pay out of pocket on a claim before insurance covers the rest, and raising it lowers the premium while shifting more of the risk to you. Our explainer on how car insurance deductibles work covers that trade-off in detail.

Registration is the other bill that arrives no matter how few miles you drive. Rules vary by state, so check with your state motor vehicle agency for exact amounts. In California, for example, registration fees depend on the vehicle type, its purchase price or declared value, the vehicle’s weight, any special plates, and even unpaid parking violations. Utah charges a registration fee each year, with a six-month option for passenger vehicles and motorcycles, and collects sales tax based on the purchase price, even on sales between family members.

Money saver: Renew registration on time. Some states charge late penalties that grow the longer you wait, and unpaid parking tickets can block an online renewal. If a car will not be driven at all, some states, including California, offer a planned nonoperation filing instead of full registration.

Depreciation: The Biggest Cost You Never See

Depreciation is the difference between what a car cost and what it is worth later. It never shows up as a bill, which is why many drivers overlook it, but AAA calls it the single largest cost of ownership. In its 2026 study, vehicles lost an average of $4,422 in value per year, on a sales-weighted average new-car price of $39,376.

Here lies the core financial argument for an older car. Depreciation is steepest in a vehicle’s first years, so a car that is already several years old has absorbed most of that loss. You cannot get the money back, but you are not paying it again. A replacement car, by contrast, starts losing value the day you buy it.

A Sample Year of Costs for a Typical Car

AAA’s 2016 study broke down a full year of ownership for an average sedan, based on a good driver, a new car purchase, and a five-year, 75,000-mile ownership period:

Cost category Annual cost Monthly cost
Depreciation $3,759 $313
Insurance $1,222 $102
Maintenance $792 $66
License, registration and taxes $687 $57
Fuel and finance charges $2,098 $175
Total $8,558 $713

The fuel and finance line is the remainder of AAA’s stated annual total, so treat it as an approximation. Your own numbers will look different, but the shape of the table is the useful part. As a car ages, depreciation shrinks toward almost nothing while maintenance and repairs grow, and insurance may fall as the vehicle’s value drops. Registration and taxes stay roughly constant.

When Keeping an Aging Car Still Beats Replacing It, and When It Does Not

Run the comparison with total costs, not payments. A new vehicle costs an average of $12,863 a year to own and operate in AAA’s 2026 study, and even a used car carries an average payment of $542 a month before fuel, insurance, maintenance, and fees. An older car that needs only routine service and standard insurance is usually far cheaper per year, precisely because its depreciation is behind it.

Keeping makes less sense when repair bills become frequent and large. A pattern of repeated shop visits, each costing hundreds or thousands of dollars, can approach the yearly cost of a replacement, without the reliability. Rising fuel use matters too. The 17.3 cents per mile average comes from a study of new vehicles, and an older car that burns noticeably more fuel costs extra every mile. Driving habits can trim that gap, as our guide to cutting fuel costs with everyday driving habits explains.

Reliability and safety deserve weight as well. A car that leaves you stranded carries costs a spreadsheet does not capture, such as missed work or tow charges.

Before deciding, add up your own year: fuel receipts, insurance premiums, maintenance and repair invoices, and the registration renewal notice. Dividing the total by your annual miles gives a cost per mile you can compare against alternatives, a calculation we walk through in what your commute really costs.

Quick wins

  • AAA’s 2026 study puts the full cost of owning and operating a new vehicle at $12,863 a year, far beyond the loan payment itself.
  • Depreciation is the single largest ownership cost, averaging $4,422 a year for new vehicles in AAA’s 2026 study.
  • Fixed costs continue whether or not you drive: AAA puts average full-coverage insurance at $2,098 a year, and registration fees come due annually.
  • AAA found 35 percent of drivers have skipped or delayed recommended service, a habit repair shops say leads to higher repair bills later.
  • An older car’s steep early depreciation is already behind it, which is often the strongest financial argument for keeping it, if repairs stay manageable.

You might be wondering

How much does it cost to own a car each year?

AAA’s 2026 Your Driving Costs study estimates $12,863 a year, or about $1,072 a month, for a new vehicle. An older paid-off car usually costs less, with less depreciation but potentially more repair spending.

What is depreciation?

It is the difference between what you paid for a car and what it is worth later. AAA calls it the largest single cost of ownership, and it hits new cars hardest in their first years.

Do registration fees differ by state?

Yes. States base fees on factors such as vehicle type, value and weight, and some add sales tax at purchase or emissions testing at renewal. Check your state motor vehicle agency for exact amounts.

Is keeping an old car cheaper than buying a replacement?

Often, because the steepest depreciation has already happened and you avoid taking on a new payment. The math changes when repairs become frequent and large, or when fuel use and reliability worsen.

These tips are general information. Prices, plans and programs vary by provider and location, so check the details with your provider before you switch or sign up.